Are music videos a site for
challenging dominant ideologies of ethnicity and gender, or do they simply reinforce simplistic stereotypes?
Ethnicity
Reinforcement:
Some videos, usually within the hip-hop and RnB genres reinforce stereotypes of black male artists. This is often done throught setting them in areas with a high concentration of black people, where some of them may originate from. This is especially seen in the west coast american gangster rap scene, with bands such as NWA and The Game.
Video: Hate It Or Love It - The Game ft. 50 Cent:
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=MPoP-BvsXxY&feature=relatedThis shows the rappers in a typical poor black area in America, claimed to be Compton in the song. It's him growing up in the environment and it turning him into what he is now, and it is full of black American stereotypes, with them getting in trouble with the police, wearing flat caps and low jeans, driving around in souped up cars. Also included are scenes involving graffiti. A lot of black rap artists focus on the rags to riches theme, and this video is no exception, with the end of the video showing him flaunting his cash.
Challenging:
Some black artists do not follow these stereotypes in their videos at all, even purposefully set out to avoid them as some female artists may do the same when trying to avoid stereotypes of femininity. This is usually done not by directly challenging the stereotype in a physical sense, but more by simply avoiding it and not adhering to the labels that may have been bestowed upon them because of their ethnicity.
Video: I'm Not Gonna Teach Your Boyfriend - Black Kids:
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=WHpo2IG7HvEIn this video the main singer/guitarist is a young black male called Reggie Youngblood. In the video he conforms to the conventions of a typical white Indie band's guitarist, and dresses and acts in the same way. This is an example of him, not deliberately challenging the black stereotype, but simply not adhering to it.
Gender
Reinforcement:
Although with the recent rise of feminism, female stereotypes are slowly become less prominent, there are still many female artsists who support the simplistic stereotype of a female artist being there for show and not for her musical talent. A lot of artists will have their songs written fro them, and will be portrayed very sexually in videos, often wearing very provocative or very little clothing.
Video: These Boots Are Made For Walking - Jessica Simpson:
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=oHPkMpaI82Q&feature=relatedThis video is a brilliant example. Jessica is shown very sexually throughout the whole thing, with shots of dismemberment and the feminine touch. She is wearing very little clothing throughout, and although in one shot she punches a male character, but this doesn't really change anything because she is wearing skimpy clothing while she does this.
Challenging:
The female stereotype shown by Jessica Simpson is one that is very common, and is also one that many female artists are keen to avoid in their work, artists such as Bjork and KT Tunstall work to escape these stereotypes, and their videos with the use of auters help them do this.
Video: Nemesis - Arch Enemy:
http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=n9AcG0glVu4Angela Gossow, the frontwoman of American Metal band Arch Enemy, completely destroys the female stereotype in all of her videos and live shows. Despite her being the typical artificial image of a woman, tall, slim and attractive, she makes full use of macho posturing, and instead of singing, she screams, something which is usually associated with males.